The Walden Effect: Homesteading Year 5. Farming, simple living, permaculture, and invention.

Homestead Blog

Innovations:

Homesteading Tags

Recent Comments



Blog Archive

User Pages

Login

About Us

Submission guidelines

Store


The history of seed legislation

Mary Nally

Nowadays, the politics of seeds mostly has to do with GMO and patented varieties. But the modern pendulum swing is just the latest in a long line of American haggling over propagules, as Mary Nally explained in the Community Food Initiative's Seed to Sustainability Workshop this past weekend.

U.S. patent office free seeds

In fact, in the mid 1800s, the US Patent Office devoted 30% of their budget to giving away free seeds. Over a million packets were distributed to American gardeners before the nation's budding seed companies stepped in.

"How are we supposed to make a buck if the government is undercutting us at every turn?" seed companies complained. By the end of the century, free seeds were (mostly) a thing of the past.

Seed companies pie chart

Fast forward ahead to the early twenty-first century, when three companies controlled 72% of world seed sales. Various types of patents now prevent you from selling patented varieties or (in the case of utility patents based on patented DNA) even saving seeds for your own use. In fact, the Community Food Initiatives staff were surprised to learn that seed swapping --- that staple of backyard gardeners in which no money changes hands --- is technically against Ohio law in many instances.

So what's a gardener to do? Mary Nally's advice is to work on changing that law. The Recomended Uniform State Seed Law (RUSSL for short) is a third-party ethical model that allows seed swaps, seed libraries, and seed banks while still protecting the economic system that makes the production of new varieties viable. Several states have already replaced outdated legislation with RUSSL-based standards. Perhaps Ohio will be next?



Want to be notified when new comments are posted on this page? Click on the RSS button after you add a comment to subscribe to the comment feed, or simply check the box beside "email replies to me" while writing your comment.


Hi Anna and Mark,

I seems like something simple and important has been forgotten?

John

Comment by John Tue Jan 23 09:37:15 2018

"seed swapping --- that staple of backyard gardeners in which no money changes hands "

I've read about a lot of incredibly stupid laws, but this one takes the cake! How are the "authorities" going to track down and prosecute people who swap seeds (even at "seed swapping events")? Seed swapping is at the bottom of "criminal" behavior and the police have more important things to do than check out neighborhood "plant swaps". Besides, many "seed swappers" actually advance genetic diversity by hybridization.

What really irritates me is that this a law that is specifically designed to help a specific industry. It does absolutely no good for anyone, and may, in fact, actually prevent diversity in the biosphere by preventing seed swappers from developing new, more resistant varieties.

The stupidity of greed never ceases to amaze me.

Comment by Nayan Tue Jan 23 10:10:55 2018
WOW
Comment by Jayne Tue Jan 23 12:01:05 2018

In cases like this where a law is clearly written for the sole benefit of some companies and to the detriment of all citizens, I would not consider it morally wrong to ignore that law.

It also seems strange to me that you can patent seeds. Especially on the basis of DNA. IIRC, the US supreme court ruled in 2013 that human genes cannot be patented because they are something that occurs in nature and is not invented. Logically, that reasoning is equally valid for non-human DNA.

But in a wider context, how can you say that a seed is an "invention" worthy of patent protection? People have been breeding plants and animals for thousands of years. If someone were to find an improvent to that process, that might be worthy of patent protection. But not the products of that process.

Comment by Roland_Smith Thu Jan 25 21:42:17 2018

One very unique homestead, $1,500 per acre, the opportunity of a lifetime