The Walden Effect: Homesteading Year 5. Farming, simple living, permaculture, and invention.

Homestead Blog


Homesteading Tags

Recent Comments

Blog Archive

User Pages


About Us

Submission guidelines


Perennial kale

Quick hoops

There are a lot of perennials with leaves that can be used as greens, but I have to admit that I prefer the flavor of our annual greens most of the time.  So you can imagine how excited I was upon hearing of perennial kale --- perhaps it could be my answer to the early spring greens shortage?

Potentially perennial kaleAnd then reality set in.  Eric Toensmeier tried out several varieties of perennial brassicas in his Massachusetts garden with very little luck and concluded that they are only reliably winter hardy to zone 8 or 9.  At the same time, the perennial brassicas detest heat, so he only recommends the currently available varieties for gardeners in the Pacific Northwest.

However, Toensmeier challenged us all to develop a new perennial brassica that can withstand hot summers and cold winters.  Brassica oleracea already contains a heaping handful of annual and perennial species and he suspects experimental crosses might yield the perennial holy kale...I mean grail.

To that end, when some kale plants overwintered last year, I left them alone.  Most bloomed and died (kale is a biennial --- that's what it does), but one survived and kept plugging along.  I can't actually remember whether this kale bloomed and I picked off the blooms or if it just kept growing.  All I know is that I've been harvesting a few leaves from my kale plant off and on for the last twelve months.  Will it survive the winter again unprotected?  Will it skip blooming again and prove itself a true perennial?  Only time will tell.

Want to be notified when new comments are posted on this page? Click on the RSS button after you add a comment to subscribe to the comment feed, or simply check the box beside "email replies to me" while writing your comment.

Was it completely unprotected over the winter?
Comment by BeninMA Thu Nov 24 15:43:52 2011
Yup, it was completely unprotected. Of course, 99% of the bed died back, so only a few plants survived the winter, and this is the only one that then didn't bolt and die.
Comment by anna Fri Nov 25 10:21:34 2011
We had a kale make 4 1/2 years until ants ate the roots and killed it. We have kale regularly overwinter and we are zone 5 here in Central Oregon.
Comment by brett Fri Nov 25 17:50:09 2011
I wonder if you have very snowy winters? I've read that zone 6 is one of the toughest for overwintering because we're too far north to have plant-friendly winters, but too far south to get a constant snow cover. Snow actually mitigates the effects of winter by insulating the soil and keeping it from getting too cold for many garden plants.
Comment by anna Sat Nov 26 09:59:34 2011

I can confirm marvellous success overwintering kale in zone 6, in a semi-arid region of Canada. I mention that it's semi-arid because we get very little snow cover, and yet our kale plants were happy all throughout the winter, even four feet up the stalk. The variety was 'Rainbow Lacinato', and a curious thing that I noticed was that as the weather got colder, the leaves turned a deep purple. I wonder if the colouring some sort of antifreeze chemical that the purple varieties have?

Now it's the end of the second summer for one of these kale plants, and it's still not dead. I'm going to leave it in the garden for a second winter and see if it's truly perennial. I've heard that perennial kale can be bitter, but this is the loveliest kale you ever did taste.

Did you have any success overwintering the solitary survivor for a second winter? I'd be very curious whether it flowered, and whether it survived. It looks a lot like our Rainbow Lacinato, only a much lighter green.

(Oh, one other thing I thought I'd mention: this spring after our surviving plants came back to life, they produced mostly flowers and not a lot of leaves. So perhaps this wasn't a very useful experiment for us :-)

Comment by Paul d'Aoust Sat Sep 1 18:22:09 2012

Paul --- I'll have to try some laciniato kale. We grew Red Russian and Dwarf Siberian last winter, which did beautifully under quick hoops. (We're in zone 6 too.)

Our possibly perennial kale overwintered again, but like yours, it didn't produce many leaves the next summer, so I eventually pulled it out. It did try to flower, but I plucked off the blooms and it eventually gave up, but still didn't make many leaves.

Comment by anna Sat Sep 1 20:11:13 2012

Hm, that's kinda sad -- I guess the search for a truly useful perennial kale goes on :) It'd be fun to try breeding something like that!

We had some Red Russian kale as well, and some of it overwintered, but it didn't fare too well either before or after the winter. It seems to be less drought-tolerant than Lacinato.

Comment by Mon Sep 3 14:03:21 2012

One very unique homestead, $1,500 per acre, the opportunity of a lifetime