The Walden Effect: Homesteading Year 5. Farming, simple living, permaculture, and invention.

Homestead Blog

Innovations:

Homesteading Tags

Recent Comments



Blog Archive

User Pages

Login

About Us

Submission guidelines

Store


The Not So Big House

The Not So Big HouseIf Wikipedia is to be believed, Sarah Susanka's The Not So Big House (published in 1998) is responsible for the birth of the tiny house movement.  The book I reviewed last weekend came out five years previously, so I'm a bit dubious about that historical assessment, but I can definitely see how Susanka's book could inspire upper middle class and upper class Americans to consider something other than a McMansion.

The photos in The Not So Big House are beautiful and the author's thesis is simple --- extra large houses are "designed to impress rather than nurture," with their numerous rooms, bigger spaces, and vaulted ceilings.  Counterintuitively, people tend to feel more comfortable in smaller dwellings, especially if you ditch the rarely-used formal spaces, use the kitchen as a focal point, and add personalized, beautiful details.

Medium-sized houseOn the other hand, I'd be hard-pressed to call any of the houses in Susanka's book "tiny."  A later book in the series, Creating The Not So Big House, presents actual house sizes, and by my math the average square footage therein is 1,839.  While smaller than the current average American house (2,700 square feet), Susanka's houses are still nearly three times the size of our living space.

I realize sound a bit like Goldilocks: "This house is too big, and this one is too small...."  Maybe the newly published Tiny Homes: Simple Shelter would be just right, but our library system doesn't have a copy, so I guess I'll go back to writing about our own trailer approach to simple housing and let the tiny house movement wander its own way.

Our chicken waterer kits come with complete instructions for building a heated waterer for easy winter care.

Trailersteading

Edited to add:


Trailersteading tells how to enjoy all the advantages of a tiny house at a fraction of the cost by living in a used mobile home.  Now available for $1.99 on Amazon.




Want to be notified when new comments are posted on this page? Click on the RSS button after you add a comment to subscribe to the comment feed, or simply check the box beside "email replies to me" while writing your comment.


Not Goldilocks at all. I remember seeing that book a long time ago (I'm a sucker for pretty coffee table books) and thinking to myself how ridiculous it was!
Comment by mitsy Wed Nov 28 09:58:17 2012
It's for a large part a matter of perspective. The houses in the pictures look quite big to me. And in a densely populated country like the Netherlands, freestanding houses are relatively rare (at least in an urban setting).
Comment by Roland_Smith Wed Nov 28 12:46:32 2012
Roland --- I'd be curious to hear what the average home size is in the Netherlands. I was trying to look that data up for Japan, but it gets complicated if you try to factor in people who live in apartments, etc. If you stumble across any data on average house size in various countries, I'd love to hear it!
Comment by anna Wed Nov 28 13:09:54 2012
Well, I think the title really says it all, Not So Big is different than tiny. They rarely mention how many people are actually occupying the houses as well. I do recall at least some plans for "cottages" in a retirement community that were definitely small but lovely in one of the books. I am not sure how many people are ready to down size to the point of tiny but I think the book was important in trying to get people to build smarter rather than just larger. I know they impacted my and husband and I when we built our house and helped us to prioritize where to allocate space and we ended up with 2200 sq feet for 6 people, which again is not tiny, a bit luxurious but not over the top. Although, I wish had spent some time with an Ikea catalog first to really look more at what was possible with smaller spaces.
Comment by Tisha A. Wed Nov 28 14:46:55 2012

The average area of a dwelling in the Netherlands is 75 m² (807 ft²) (according to this webpage in Dutch). This obviously includes apartments and houses that are subdivided. It does vary quite a bit by province, though.

According to the same webpage, the numbers for some other European countries are: Belgium 119 m² (1280 ft²), Germany 122 m² (1313 ft²), Italy 125 m² (1345 ft²) and scandinavia 160 m² (1722 ft²).

The Netherlands is relatively densely populated, with most people living in towns, where houses are smaller on average. Most houses here are built in brick and/or concrete, so they are more expensive than wooden framed houses. On the other hand, they can last a lot longer. My apartment complex was built in 1962. And it it not uncommon for houses to reach ages of a century or more. The oldest existing house that is still in use dates back to 1130!

Comment by Roland_Smith Wed Nov 28 14:48:04 2012

This looks like a fun book to browse through. I think our house(s) is about the size you mentioned (1800 sf or so) although we're getting ready to be 8 people in February and spend all day long at home (homeschooling). We were in just over 400 sf winter before last (when baby 5 was still very much a baby) and it worked but it was depressingly (at times) small. Maybe because DH and I didn't have a bedroom or any space to call "ours." We also didn't have a dryer so we did all our laundry on the clotheslines or on two folding racks inside when it was wet. What we have now is two mobile homes hooked together with a set of 3 broad stairs (and an enormous pavilion-style roof over the whole mess) and it works well for us. It will be even better once we finish the renovations which will take us from 1 bathroom to 3 (such largesse, I know!) and make our kitchen more the center of our living areas. We have room to feed 20 people pretty comfortably and that's important to me. And we have room for everyone to sit around and chat. Someday we'll even have a guest bedroom. We have never aspired to a McMansion though. As much as I love the tiny houses, I can't really see DH and myself moving into one, even in retirement, because I want to have room for my kids and grandkids to come home (my oldest is 11; yes, I'm planning ahead :))

Comment by Lindsey in AL Thu Nov 29 09:38:53 2012
Lindsey --- Your combination mobile home(s) sounds fascinating! Any chance you'd be interested in being e-interviewed for the book I'm currently writing about living in a trailer? If so, drop me an email at anna@kitenet.net. But don't feel obliged --- I enjoyed your comment regardless. :-)
Comment by anna Thu Nov 29 10:05:27 2012

One very unique homestead, $1,500 per acre, the opportunity of a lifetime